THE ISLAND (PG13) starring Ewan McGregor and Scarlett Johansson

The Scrutiny says, “Maybe On A Plane Or In A Hotel” "75.5" out of 100 Points.
For The Scrutniny rating system click HERE

"J"s Review: Acting: 8/10, Ensemble: 9/10, Cinematography: 7/10, Story: 5/10, Soundtrack: 8/10, Overall: 43/50

Total: 80/100

By the skin of its teeth, this movie made it to being a renter for me. The downfall was the story. Solid acting by great actors that worked well together. Visually it was nice, although completely unoriginal. But the story is a benchmark of unoriginality. As a movie, it was confused as to whether it was going to be sci-fi or action. As a Sci-Fi film it was entertaining but as an action film it was the usual drivel of CG shite (the use of “shite” is in honor of Ewan McGregor, one of my favorite actors). Overall I was entertained but you must check your intellect at the door.

80 Points: "Keep Your Blockbuster Card And Rent It"

~Jason

"B"s Review: Acting: 7/10, Ensemble: 8/10, Cinematography: 7/10, Story: 4/10, Soundtrack: 5/10, Overall: 40/50

Total: 71/100

I was confused and disappointed. If you’ve watched Gattaca , The Truman Show and Blade Runner, then you’ve watched The Island. If you’ve ever watched two news crews covering the same story, then you’ll understand this film retelling the same story, again. I wanted something more; different. I had high hopes. The acting was great, and I was impressed with Ewan McGregor’s boyish innocence - until he escapes, then suddenly he becomes streetwise. Typical Michael Bay – big, bold and choppy. I usually enjoy nearly all movies, but I found myself checking my watch frequently. Enjoyable, but done.

71 Points: "Watch It On A Plane Or In A Hotel Room"

~Brock